Articles

HELOC vs. Cash-Out Refinance: Which Costs Less for Your Situation

A HELOC and a cash-out refinance can both deliver $50,000, but they reprice different debt. In one example, the HELOC costs about $51,000 less over ten years, and the existing mortgage rate decides which option wins.

All articles
Rene SolorzanoRene Solorzano4 min read

A homeowner who needs $50,000 has two common ways to get it. A home equity line of credit (HELOC) opens a credit line that sits alongside the existing first mortgage. A cash-out refinance replaces the first mortgage with a larger loan and pays the difference out in cash. Both use home equity, but they reprice different debt, and that difference shapes which one costs less.

What happens to the first mortgage is the central question. A HELOC leaves it alone. If the current loan carries a lower rate than the new money, that rate stays in place on the bulk of the balance, and the new rate applies only to the amount drawn. A cash-out refinance reprices the whole balance at the new rate, charges closing costs, and typically restarts the loan term. The cost of the cash is therefore the cost of the new money plus the cost of moving the old money onto a new rate.

Consider a home worth $500,000 with a $250,000 first mortgage at 5.25%, 25 years remaining. The calculator defaults to combined borrowing of 80% of value, which is $400,000 here. Subtracting the existing mortgage leaves $150,000 of available credit, so a $50,000 draw fits easily. The HELOC in this example charges 8.5%, with a 10-year interest-only draw period followed by 20 years of principal and interest.

The cash-out refinance has to produce $50,000 after its own closing costs. At a 6.75% fixed rate over 30 years, with closing costs of 2.5% of the new loan, that requires a loan of about $307,700, with roughly $7,700 in closing costs.

The two options look like this over the first ten years:

HELOCCash-out refinance
Monthly payment, first 10 years$1,852.29$1,995.69
Monthly payment, years 11 and later$1,932.03$1,995.69
Upfront closing costsNone assumedAbout $7,700
Debt still owed after 10 years$236,362$262,465
Total cost over 10 years$408,636$459,639

The HELOC payment in the first ten years is the existing $1,498.12 mortgage payment plus $354.17 of interest on the draw. The refinance payment is higher from the first month, by about $143, because the whole $307,700 now carries the 6.75% rate.

The total cost in the last row adds the payments, the closing costs, and the balance still owed, then subtracts the $50,000 received. It counts the remaining balance as a cost because it still has to be repaid. In this example, the HELOC costs about $51,000 less over the decade. That result follows from the assumptions above, which are a 5.25% existing rate, a 6.75% fixed refinance rate, closing costs of 2.5%, and no HELOC fees. A different set of inputs would produce a different gap.

Most of the gap comes from the first mortgage. The HELOC keeps the 5.25% loan, while the refinance moves all $250,000 to 6.75%. The refinance also stretches repayment on the balance already in place. The HELOC's 8.5% rate applies only to the $50,000 drawn, so it carries the smaller share of the cost.

The HELOC payment is not steady, though. When the draw period ends after ten years, principal repayment begins, and the $50,000 is repaid over 20 years, raising the HELOC payment by $79.74 a month to $433.91. The refinance payment does not change at that point, because it was a single loan on a fixed rate. A borrower who plans around the lower early payment should plan for that step as well.

HELOC rates are usually variable, so the 8.5% figure can move. If the draw rate rises to 9.5%, the interest-only payment grows by $41.66 a month, or about $5,000 over the ten years in this example. That narrows the gap without reversing it here, but the margin depends on how far the rate moves and how long it stays there.

The answer can flip, and the existing mortgage rate is the main lever. In this model, the HELOC stays cheaper over ten years until the existing rate reaches about 7.2%, which is above the 6.75% refinance rate. The HELOC's 8.5% draw rate is the expensive piece, so a refinance only comes out ahead when the first mortgage is already costly. A homeowner with a loan near the new market rate should expect the two options to look much closer.

Timing matters too. A HELOC charges interest only on what has been drawn, so a homeowner who spreads a renovation over two years may pay far less than the figures above. A refinance pays out its full amount at closing and charges interest on all of it from the start. If the cash is needed all at once, the two products sit closer together than the timing example suggests.

The line also has limits. Available credit depends on the home's value, and lenders can change or freeze a line if the terms or the home's value change. A cash-out refinance fixes the loan amount at closing. A line's flexibility suits an uncertain need, but lenders can still change its terms.

Before comparing offers, the existing mortgage rate, the planned timing of the cash, and the quoted fees from each lender set the terms of the comparison. The HELOC Calculator shows the credit limit and both payment phases for a specific home, and the Refinance Break-Even Calculator shows how long a new first mortgage takes to recover its closing costs.