Articles

When the Fed Raises Rates, Why Can Mortgage Rates Still Improve?

The Fed sets a short-term rate, but a 30-year mortgage rate is set in longer-term markets, so the two can move in different directions. This example shows what each quarter point does to the monthly payment and total interest on a $320,000 loan.

All articles
Rene SolorzanoRene Solorzano4 min read

When the Federal Reserve raises rates, mortgage rates don't always rise the same day. The Fed sets a short-term interest rate, the rate banks charge each other for overnight loans. A 30-year mortgage is a long-term loan, and its rate is set by longer-term markets. The two are connected, but the link is indirect. The St. Louis Fed notes that when the Fed changes policy, mortgage rates usually don't respond right away, because they are set in long-term markets that weigh expectations about future rates, inflation, and the economy.

Mortgage rates depend on a handful of longer-term forces. Inflation expectations matter, because investors and lenders want a return that holds up over decades. The 10-year Treasury yield serves as a benchmark, though mortgage rates usually sit above it to reflect extra risk and costs. Investor demand for mortgage-backed securities, the bundles of home loans that investors buy, and lenders' own origination and servicing costs also feed into the rate you're offered. Each of these can move on its own schedule.

That's why mortgage rates can improve while the Fed is raising its short-term rate. Markets react to what they expect to happen, not only to the decision made at a single meeting. Suppose investors already expect the Fed to raise rates by a full point over the next year. Long-term rates have likely absorbed that expectation. If the Fed then raises rates by a quarter point, as expected, little new information has arrived, and long-term rates may stay steady. If new data suggests inflation is cooling and future increases will be smaller, long-term rates can fall, even on a day the Fed raises its rate. The St. Louis Fed has also noted that when the Fed lowers short-term rates, long-term mortgage rates can stay high or even rise if inflation expectations or economic uncertainty increase.

For you, the practical point is that the Fed's decision and the rate on your loan can move in different directions. The rate that affects your payment is the mortgage rate itself. So the useful question is what a given mortgage rate does to your monthly bill and the total interest you pay, not what the Fed did last week.

The example below changes only the rate. It's a $400,000 home with 20% down, which leaves a $320,000 loan over 30 years. Property taxes are $400 a month, and homeowners insurance is about $167 a month. There's no HOA fee, and there's no mortgage insurance because the down payment is 20%. Every rate in the table is a hypothetical example, not a current quote.

Rate (hypothetical)Principal and interestTotal monthly housing costTotal interest over 30 years
6.00%$1,918.56$2,485.56$370,682
6.25%$1,970.30$2,537.30$389,306
6.50%$2,022.62$2,589.62$408,142
6.75%$2,075.51$2,642.51$427,185
7.00%$2,128.97$2,695.97$446,428

The total monthly housing cost is the principal and interest payment, plus the $400 in taxes and $167 in insurance. At 6.50%, the principal and interest payment is $2,022.62 a month. Over 30 years, that adds up to about $728,000 in payments, and after subtracting the $320,000 you borrowed, the interest comes to $408,142.

Each quarter point changes the monthly principal and interest payment by about $52 and the total interest by roughly $19,000 over the full loan. Going from 6.50% to 6.75% adds $52.89 a month and $19,043 of interest. The effect is steady across the range, which makes it easier to plan around than the headline rate suggests.

Only some of the costs move with the rate. Principal and interest change, and so does total interest. Taxes, insurance, and HOA fees stay the same in this example, since they don't depend on the mortgage rate. That's why the total monthly cost moves a little less than the principal and interest line alone.

With a fixed-rate loan, the rate you get at closing applies for the life of the loan, unless you later refinance. That makes the rate you're actually offered the number that governs your payment, not the rate you hoped for months earlier.

A homeowner comparing a refinance has a different question than a buyer. A refinancing homeowner already has a loan, so the comparison is between the current rate and the new one, after closing costs, over the time they expect to keep the loan. A buyer has no existing loan to compare. The comparison is with renting, with other uses of the down payment, and with the monthly budget the purchase requires.

To see how the rate changes your own numbers, open the Mortgage Calculator and enter a $400,000 home price, an $80,000 down payment, a 30-year term, a 6.50% interest rate, a 1.20% property tax rate, and a 0.50% insurance rate. Note the total monthly payment and the total interest. Then change only the interest rate to 6.75% and compare the two results.