Rene Solorzano2 min readCap rate and cash-on-cash return both show up early in a commercial property analysis, and they answer different questions. Cap rate is net operating income divided by purchase price. Cash-on-cash return is the cash left after debt service divided by the cash invested. One ignores financing, and the other depends on it.
Take an eight-unit multifamily property priced at $1,200,000. Gross rent is $144,000 a year, and a 5% vacancy allowance, $24,000 of operating expenses, and $18,000 of property taxes and insurance bring net operating income (NOI) to $94,800. Dividing NOI by price gives a cap rate of 7.9%.
The investor puts $300,000 down and borrows $900,000 at 7% over 30 years. Annual principal and interest comes to $72,000, which is a loan constant of 8.0%, the annual debt service divided by the loan amount. After debt service, the property leaves a $22,800 annual cushion, and dividing that by the $300,000 invested gives a cash-on-cash return of 7.6%.
Borrowing lowered the return rather than raising it. Leverage lifts cash-on-cash only when the loan constant is below the cap rate. Here the constant is 8.0% and the cap rate is 7.9%, so the debt costs more each year than the property earns on its price. Had the loan rate been 6.9% or lower, the constant would have sat under the cap rate and borrowing would have raised the return. At 6% the same property shows a 10.0% cash-on-cash return, and at 5% it shows 12.3%, because the loan constant falls to 6.4% and the spread opens up.
The same loan terms also drive debt coverage. The debt service coverage ratio (DSCR) divides NOI by annual debt service, so at $94,800 of NOI and $72,000 of debt service, the property's DSCR is 1.32x. At 6% the DSCR rises to 1.46x, and at 5% to 1.64x.
Neither metric covers everything. Cap rate ignores financing, so it lets investors compare properties and markets on equal terms but says nothing about what a particular loan does to returns. Cash-on-cash shows the first year's cash only. It ignores the principal paid down each year, the change in value over the holding period, and any sale proceeds. A property can show a weak first-year cash-on-cash return and still produce a strong total return if the loan amortizes quickly and the price rises, which is where internal rate of return and equity multiple come in.
The first decision in the example is whether to take the loan at the quoted rate, since at 7% the property's own yield barely covers its debt. The second is which of the two numbers a lender or partner is looking at, since a cap rate figure can make a deal look stronger than its financing does. Entering the NOI, price, loan amount, rate, and term into the DSCR Calculator shows the cap rate, debt service, DSCR, and cash flow for a specific property, so you can see which of the two figures a given loan leaves you with.