Articles

What Happens to a BRRRR Deal When the Appraisal Comes In Low

A lower BRRRR appraisal can leave more cash in a property while reducing debt payments. See how ARV and LTV affect refinance proceeds, cash flow, and capital recovery.

All articles
Rene SolorzanoRene Solorzano3 min read

A BRRRR deal (buy, rehab, rent, refinance, repeat) depends heavily on a number the investor does not control: the appraisal. The refinance loan is a percentage of the appraised after-repair value, or ARV, so the appraisal decides how much of the investor’s cash comes back out.

An investor buys a property for $140,000, pays $4,500 in purchase closing costs, and spends $50,000 on rehab, for $194,500 invested in total. It appraises at $250,000, and the lender refinances at 75% loan-to-value, or LTV, producing a $187,500 loan. After $3,750 in refinance closing costs, $183,750 comes back, which leaves $10,750 in the property. That remainder is the cash left in the deal. Because it is a small difference between two large numbers, anything that moves the appraisal moves it sharply in percentage terms.

At 75% LTV, the lender returns 75 cents of loan for every appraised dollar, so every dollar the appraisal misses leaves 75 cents more in the property. A $5,000 miss leaves $3,750 more. A 5% miss on $250,000, which is $12,500, leaves $9,375 more and takes the cash left from $10,750 to $20,125, an 87% increase. This example holds the $3,750 refinance closing costs constant.

How a lower appraisal changes the numbers

The table below uses rent of $2,000 a month, expenses of $560 a month, and the base case’s refinance terms of 5.31% over 30 years, which carry a $1,042.36 monthly payment on the $187,500 loan. The payment shrinks in proportion to the loan as the appraisal falls. Cash-on-cash is annual cash flow divided by the cash left, and payback is the cash left divided by monthly cash flow.

AppraisalChangeCash left in dealMonthly cash flowCash-on-cashPayback$250,000Base$10,750$397.6444.4%27 months$245,000-2%$14,500$418.4934.6%35 months$237,500-5%$20,125$449.7626.8%45 months$230,000-8%$25,750$481.0322.4%54 months$212,467-15.0%$38,900$554.1317.1%70 months

Monthly cash flow rises as the appraisal falls, because a smaller loan carries a smaller payment. At $230,000 the property produces $481.03 a month instead of $397.64. Rent and expenses are unchanged, so cash flow holds up, but the money stays inside the property longer, which is why cash-on-cash falls from 44.4% to 22.4% and payback stretches from 27 months to about 54. A low appraisal can also signal that the market values the property below the investor’s assumption, which would mean less equity than planned.

The capital-recovery cushion

A deal’s cushion is how far the appraisal can fall before it crosses a chosen capital-recovery line. For illustration, this post uses 80% as that line, with 100% meaning the refinance returns all of the original capital. Here the refinance recovers 94.5%. Full recovery would take an appraisal of about $264,333, which is 5.7% above the assumed ARV. The 80% line sits at about $212,467, so the appraisal can fall 15.0% before the deal crosses it. That cushion is specific to this deal. If rehab runs $10,000 over, total investment becomes $204,500, the 80% line moves to about $223,133, and the cushion shrinks to 10.7%.

A lower LTV works the same way. Because the loan equals the LTV times the ARV, a lender offering 70% instead of 75% has the same effect as an appraisal 6.7% lower. At $250,000 and 70%, the cash left is $23,250 before any miss at all.

A deal that needs its full ARV to meet its capital-recovery line has no room for a lower appraisal. A deal that still clears 80% at a 10% lower appraisal has margin built in, though that margin usually costs something, either a lower purchase price or a smaller rehab, and it narrows the set of deals that qualify. Cash left in the property has a time cost as well, since capital tied up for four or five years cannot fund the next purchase.

To find a specific deal’s cushion, lower the ARV in the BRRRR Calculator in $5,000 steps. The cash left rises by $3,750 each time, and the step where it reaches the amount you are willing to leave in the property is that deal’s cushion.