Rene Solorzano2 min readPutting 20% down instead of 10% on a $400,000 home means committing another $40,000 upfront. You borrow less, pay less interest, and avoid PMI in this example. With 10% down, you keep that $40,000 available for other purposes, but take on a larger mortgage and the added cost of PMI.
The difference is not just what you save on the mortgage. It is also what you give up by putting more of your cash into the home. A larger down payment reduces your borrowing costs, but leaves less money available for repairs, unexpected expenses, or other priorities. A smaller down payment preserves that flexibility, but comes with a larger loan and, in this example, PMI.
How 10% and 20% down compare
Consider a $400,000 home financed with a 30-year fixed mortgage at 6.5%.
| 10% down | 20% down | |
|---|---|---|
| Down payment | $40,000 | $80,000 |
| Starting loan balance | $360,000 | $320,000 |
| Monthly principal and interest | About $2,275 | About $2,022 |
| Scheduled interest over 30 years | $459,160 | $408,142 |
The 20% down option reduces scheduled interest by $51,018 over 30 years.
PMI makes the early monthly gap larger
With 10% down, the example adds $165 per month in private mortgage insurance (PMI), bringing the initial monthly difference between the two options to about $418.
PMI is projected to become eligible for cancellation when the loan reaches 80% of the home's original value, after 7 years and 11 months. By then, cumulative PMI paid is projected to be $15,675. If PMI has not been cancelled earlier, automatic termination is projected when the loan reaches 78% loan-to-value, after 9 years and 1 month.
Once PMI ends, the monthly difference narrows because the $165 insurance charge is no longer part of the 10% down payment's monthly cost. The remaining difference comes from the larger loan balance.
You can compare loan amounts, rates, and terms with the Mortgage Calculator, and examine PMI costs and projected termination milestones with the PMI Calculator.
What could the extra $40,000 do instead?
Putting 20% down turns an additional $40,000 of cash into home equity and reduces the cost of financing the purchase. But equity is not as readily available as money in a bank account, and that cash could have other uses.
Putting 10% down leaves the $40,000 available for repairs, unexpected expenses, or other priorities. You could also invest it, potentially earning a return that offsets or exceeds some of the additional mortgage interest and PMI.
The PMI Calculator applies a PMI rate based on your credit score range. Enter your home price, down payment, and credit score range to estimate your monthly PMI, when it may be eligible for cancellation, and how much PMI you could pay over time.